Question about interpreting the Milk results
I am confused about the milk results on this site. Can someone help me out here? The dates listed say "best by" date. Does that mean that we should be subtracting 18 days from that date to determine the amount of measured isotopes on the date of packaging? What I want to know is when did iodine and cesium begin to be found in milk based on the date of bottling, not on the best by date. But I'm not sure how to figure that out based on these results.


Here's the info from BRAWM
4/13/2011 8:40pm: Major revision note: We just performed a major revision of our preliminary milk measurements. Our activity measurements for milk with a "best by" date after 4/4/2011 were accidentally calculated for the "best by" date itself, rather than an earlier date such as the purchase date. Since milk can be on the shelves starting almost 18 days before the "best by" date, our numbers after 4/4/2011 did not accurately reflect the maximum activity that the radioisotopes could have at the time of purchase. Incidentally, our first two milk measurements were not corrected at all and therefore reflect the activity at the time of measurement. The original numbers are at the bottom of the page for reference.
In order to make a valid comparison between all milk samples, we decided to correct all milk samples to represent the activity at their time of bottling -- this is 18 days before the "best by" date. This revision does not change the Cs-134 or Cs-137 numbers since they have long radioactive half-lives. The I-131 activity increases by factors of 2 to 5 because of its 8 day half-life. Please note that though all I-131 activities have increased due to this revision, the levels are still very low -- one would have to consume at least 1,900 liters of milk to receive the same radiation dose as a cross-country airplane trip.
In addition, two new milk measurements were added to the table. The Cs-134 and Cs-137 levels are very low but are trending upward. This trend is probably due to a combination of the uptake rate by both the cow and grass. We'll continue to watch the milk levels to see how the iodine and cesium end up concentrated or dispersed with time.
Read the BRAWM info on Milk testing
I believe their results are based on the estimated BOTTLING date (thus providing for the half life decay of radiodine) so that they have already doen the math to tell you what the amounts were when bottled.
They explained this in a note on their milk results when they made the change to reflect the data based on the concern raised by you and I think they have accounted for that.
Take a look at the results page on the monitoring site and their updates below the links.
Thanks Bill, but that's what
Thanks Bill, but that's what is confusing about it. I read their note about the changes made, but on the table where the data is, the left side column still says "best by date". So, is that the best by date or the bottling date? And if it is the best by date, should i be subtracting 18 days to determine bottling date.
Thanks, Bill. It's always
Thanks, Bill. It's always nice when long-standing forum members help explain. This all seems correct, but I will have to confirm with our software guys.
Yes, thanks Bill. That is
Yes, thanks Bill. That is exactly what the analysis code is doing.
The activity is calculated for the bottling date, so it is the maximum activity the consumer would encounter.
Mark [BRAWM Team Member]
Thanks Mark and any new milk, spinach etc to report?
I like to make sure we are all kind of on the same page with the data.
But I want MORE Data asap, especially milk, spinach, rain and mushrooms and any other veggies.