As mentioned previously, we in fact distill our water before placing it into our detection system. Distilling does not remove any contaminants, radioactive or otherwise.
Slight amendment: The main purpose of distilling, of course, is to kill pathogens like bacteria, so in that sense I suppose it is removing one type of contaminant.
Distillation may not be the best term for this. We are basically doing a reduction of water volume by using a drying oven. This will remove water through vaporization leaving behind a smaller volume of water with the original particulates. This reduction increases our sensitivity since we can provide a higher concentration within our maranelli beaker. It was hypothesized early on that this reduction may actually remove the isotopes of interest from our samples, but we tested a sample with a 5 to 1 reduction and the same sample without reduction and we saw, within statistical error, no difference in the measured activity concentration in the initial sample. This shows that our process maintained the isotopes within the volume during the reduction.
As mentioned previously, we
As mentioned previously, we in fact distill our water before placing it into our detection system. Distilling does not remove any contaminants, radioactive or otherwise.
Tim [BRAWM Team Member]
I'm confused... distilling
I'm confused... distilling water does not remove impurities/contaminants? Does it not reduce them at least?
fwiw, wikipedia says:
fwiw, wikipedia says: "Distilled water is water that has many of its impurities removed through distillation"
so, i'm still confused...
Slight amendment: The main
Slight amendment: The main purpose of distilling, of course, is to kill pathogens like bacteria, so in that sense I suppose it is removing one type of contaminant.
BRAWM?
Is this something the BRAWM team can answer?
Anyone know?
Anyone know?
where would the
where would the contamination go? it doesn't just disappear. seems to me that even if the water turns to vapor, the bad stuff sticks to it.
How about Reverse Osmosis
Reverse Osmosis has been considered a good option, but still need to know from BRAWN if that is the case.
Distillation may not be the
Distillation may not be the best term for this. We are basically doing a reduction of water volume by using a drying oven. This will remove water through vaporization leaving behind a smaller volume of water with the original particulates. This reduction increases our sensitivity since we can provide a higher concentration within our maranelli beaker. It was hypothesized early on that this reduction may actually remove the isotopes of interest from our samples, but we tested a sample with a 5 to 1 reduction and the same sample without reduction and we saw, within statistical error, no difference in the measured activity concentration in the initial sample. This shows that our process maintained the isotopes within the volume during the reduction.
ahhh, so you are not using
ahhh, so you are not using the "distilled" water, but rather the water left behind by the distillation process. that makes a lot more sense... thanks
Alex